Property development offers substantial opportunities for builders but navigating complex tax rules like Capital Gains Tax (CGT) and Goods and Services Tax (GST) requires careful planning. Here’s what builders must consider to ensure successful and compliant property developments.
Capital Gains Tax (CGT): The Basics
- Main Residence Exemption: If an individual sells their primary residence, the property is typically exempt from CGT. Builders must exercise caution to ensure this exemption clearly applies and should always seek professional advice when uncertain.
- Investment Property & CGT Discounts: Individuals or trusts selling investment properties may qualify for a CGT discount if the property has been held for more than 12 months. This reduces taxable gains significantly, improving overall investment profitability.
- Company Structures: Builders using company structures for property development or investment cannot access CGT discounts. Any profits made are taxed at corporate rates, making strategic tax planning crucial.
Understanding GST in Property Development
GST considerations vary significantly depending on the structure, intention and business model of the development project:
- Margin Scheme: Often used to reduce GST liability by applying GST only to the margin (the difference between the sale price and original purchase price), rather than the full sale price.
- GST Mechanics: Understanding the timing, calculation, and reporting requirements of GST is critical for compliance and cash flow management.
Choosing the Right Business Model
Selecting the most suitable business model for your property development projects is crucial, as each approach comes with its own set of structures, complexities, and strategic considerations. Understanding these models helps in choosing the right structure and clarifies the roles and relationships between parties involved.
- Small-Scale or Individual Projects: These projects are usually single, standalone developments driven by individual developers or small partnerships. Typically, they’re managed personally or through simple business structures like sole traders or basic company and trust setups. They have fewer complexities in terms of financing and governance, but developers still need to ensure appropriate liability protection and tax efficiency.
- Builders with Multiple Roles: Many builders undertake property development alongside their primary construction business. In this scenario, the builder wears multiple hats—both as developer and contractor. This dual role requires clear structuring to manage risks and delineate responsibilities, particularly in financial management, tax planning, and contractual obligations. Often, builders in this model will establish separate entities to clearly distinguish between their construction operations and their development projects.
- Regular Developers Engaging External Builders: Some property developers consistently undertake projects but choose to outsource construction work to external builders. Here, the key considerations involve managing relationships with contractors through clear contractual terms, detailed project oversight, and maintaining separate entities to manage legal and financial risks effectively. This approach offers flexibility but demands meticulous management to ensure consistent quality and project profitability.
- Collaborative Multi-Party Developments: Complex projects involving multiple partners or stakeholders require sophisticated business structures. These collaborations necessitate detailed planning, clearly defined contractual agreements, joint venture arrangements, and sometimes special-purpose vehicles (SPVs). Such structures effectively manage risk allocation, capital contributions, and profit-sharing arrangements, enabling clear governance and accountability among all participants.
- Professional, Large-Scale Development Operations: At the top end of the scale, professional property developers operate extensive, large-scale developments. These projects are supported by significant capital, structured finance arrangements, and robust corporate governance. The entities involved are usually professionally managed companies or sophisticated SPVs with specialist management teams dedicated to handling complex projects, extensive compliance obligations, and detailed financial reporting.
By clearly identifying and selecting the right business model, those looking to play in the property developer space can effectively structure their operations to manage risk, optimise financial outcomes, and streamline relationships between all involved parties.
Funding Projects: Navigating Lending Arrangements
Property development lending arrangements can be significantly more complex than standard home loans or typical business lending such as working capital finance. These specialised financing arrangements require careful planning, clear communication, and strategic management.
Having a close relationship with your lender offers substantial advantages. Experienced lenders can provide holistic solutions, including specialised construction finance, private wealth guidance and structured tax-effective debt deals. Leveraging their in-house construction risk capabilities and broad industry experience can enhance your project’s likelihood of success, ensuring both parties achieve their desired outcomes.
Maximising Margins as a Builder-Developer
When a builder steps into the role of developer, they unlock the opportunity to maximise margins beyond traditional building contracts. By developing land, the builder captures the uplift in land value resulting from the improvement, enjoying both the construction margin and the enhanced market value of the completed development.
Example
Consider a (simplified) scenario involving an undeveloped residential block of land purchased for $800,000. The builder-developer decides to subdivide the land and construct two townhouses. Upon completion, each townhouse sells for $1,200,000, generating total sales of $2,400,000.
Initial Land Cost: $800,000
Construction Cost: Assuming realistic construction costs of $500,000 per townhouse, the total build cost is $1,000,000.
Total Project Cost: Land ($800,000) + Construction ($1,000,000) = $1,800,000
Total Sales Revenue: 2 townhouses x $1,200,000 each = $2,400,000
Total Profit: $2,400,000 – $1,800,000 = $600,000
By comparison, a builder who solely undertakes a traditional building contract with a typical 20% gross profit margin on the $1,000,000 construction cost would achieve a profit of $200,000.
This comparison highlights the significant advantage for a builder acting as developer, who can substantially enhance profitability by capturing both the construction margin and the uplift in land value.
Feasibility Tools: Planning for Success
Conducting a thorough feasibility analysis is essential to avoid embarking on projects with limited financial upside or, worse, potential losses. A robust feasibility assessment enables builders to accurately forecast project profitability and effectively manage financial risks.
To support builders in making informed decisions, we’ve developed a specialised feasibility tool that evaluates potential projects comprehensively.
Note: While our feasibility tool significantly aids the decision-making process, it is critical to seek expert advice before making any final decisions.
DOWNLOAD OUR FEASIBILITY TOOL
Balancing Risk and Reward
While the financial upside of the builder-developer model is attractive, it’s critical to understand and manage the associated risks:
- Concentration Risk: Taking on the dual roles of builder and developer puts “all your eggs in one basket,” increasing exposure to market fluctuations, financing challenges, and operational risks.
- Structuring and Tax Risks: Poor initial project structuring can lead to significant tax inefficiencies and legal complications. It’s crucial to seek specialist advice upfront to ensure the right entities and contractual structures are in place.
- Distraction from Core Business: Managing development projects alongside client projects can lead to stretched resources and compromised service quality. It’s essential to manage resources carefully, ensuring development work doesn’t negatively impact core business activities.
- Financial Complexity: The financial complexity increases significantly when developing properties. Maintaining crystal clear financial visibility, accurate cash flow forecasting, and comprehensive cost tracking is crucial for success.
Prescription for Success
To effectively manage these risks and realise the potential upside in property development, follow these key steps:
- Feasibility Analysis: Undertake thorough feasibility studies, ensuring all project costs—including tax implications, financing, holding costs, and professional fees—are accurately accounted for before committing to land purchases or getting involved in development projects.
- Operational Planning: Develop robust operational plans that enable the effective management of existing client commitments alongside your own developments. This involves resource allocation, clear timelines, and contingency planning. If you need additional operational resources, this needs to be factored into your overall net margin.
- Financial Visibility: Establish strong financial reporting processes, ensuring you have clear, timely insights into your project’s financial health – across your core business projects and your own developments. If you lack in-house financial expertise, consider engaging an outsourced CFO to provide specialist oversight.
- Specialist Tax Advice: Engage with a tax specialist experienced in building, construction, and property development to optimise your project structures and ensure compliance, minimising tax liabilities and enhancing profitability.
Need Tailored Advice?
Understanding financial complexities is crucial to successful property development. Schedule a free consultation today with our team to explore how you can safely unlock property development opportunities.
BOOK A FREE CONSULTATION
